Comment on this article |
Email this article |
News :: Human Rights
Do Vegan Prisoners Have A Right To Nonviolent Food?
by Law And Ethics
24 Mar 2014
There is a growing movement to recognize vegan prisoners' rights.
Click on image for a larger version
Davie McDonald, vegan, lost 50 pounds while in jail for a dubious drug charge
NONVIOLENT FOOD...POSITIVE CHANGE
Jails serving higher percentages of vegan food find health care expense and food costs are reduced
and that prisoners are more peaceful because of less adrenalin and uric acid in the diet.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit held in a case that "when a person sincerely
holds beliefs dealing with issues of ‘ultimate concern' that for her occupy a
‘place parallel to that filled by ... God in traditionally religious persons,' those beliefs
represent her religion."
Beliefs "need not be based on ... a mainstream faith." In other words, one need not be affiliated with a particular faith to have a right to a vegan meal.
RLUIPA is the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act -
Arizona's Maricopa County Jail has eliminated meat from the menu.
The Summit County Jail in Akron Ohio has in the last 3 months had a vegetarian kitchen. Prisoners who want meat may buy it in the vending machines.
Ohio prisons have removed pig flesh from menu after Muslim lawsuit
Florida's Department of Corrections has eliminated mammal flesh from the menu.
Florida is being asked to provide kosher diet upon request.
18 organizations including the ACLU, the National Association of Evangelicals, the American Jewish Committee,
the Aleph Institute, the Rabbinical Council of America, and the Hindu American Foundation — have filed amicus briefs
asking that Florida give kosher food upon request to inmates. 35 states already do.
Read more here: http://www.miamiherald.com/2013/05/18/3403274/kosher-prison-food-lawsuit
Professor Richard Schwartz, author of an online course in Jewish vegetarianism has said that it is impossible to be kosher if not a vegetarian since some blood always remains in the smallest arterioles of a butchered animal. http://jewishveg.com/schwartz
Other vegan meal situations
vegan prisoner meals
Several thousand health professionals recommending vegan diet http://pcrm.org
THE MARK OF A DRAGGING FOOT ON THE SANDS OF TIME
Dave McDonald was in jail in California on a dubious drug charge. A vegan who had been vegetarian
for 42 years, the 73 year old man was not given vegan mails by the Marin County Jail. He lost 50 pounds. Being a philosophical vegan was not acceptable to jail officials.
He had to be affiliated with a particular organized religion.
Federal judge Shira A. Scheindli refused to order officials at Rikers Island Prison in New York
to provide vegan meals on command
For some Illinois prisoners, the DC based Weston A Price Foundation, a foundation which promotes animal flesh and whose funding is questionable,
is suing on behalf of some Illinois prisoners. Its objective: more cadaver pieces on the menu.
The foundation promotes among other carrion products cod liver oil, which is full of radiation,
mercury etc. Dick Gregory: Eating fish oil is like eating the filter out of a car.
In some prisons, only the Bible or the Koran are allowed, no other spiritual texts and nothing for atheists.
Phone systems have been privatized. Prisoners must have someone on the outside willing to pay the outrageous collect call charges of ATT and other phone systems.
Rather than give your books to Goodwill or the Salvation Army which throw away 90% of their hardbound books, why not donate them to a prison library, one which is not draconian in its rules.
Prisoners have a right to a safe environment, free of rape or physical battering.
Prisoners have a right to a clean environment.
VEGANS IN PRISON FOR NONVIOLENT ANIMAL RIGHTS ACTIONS
The picture is of Dave McDonald who lost 50 pounds during a 99 day sentence on a dubious drug charge.
This work is in the public domain