US Indymedia Global Indymedia Publish About us
Printed from Boston IMC : http://boston.indymedia.org/
Boston.Indymedia
IVAW Winter Soldier

Winter Soldier
Testimonies
Brad Presente

Other Local News

Spare Change News
Open Media Boston
Somerville Voices
Cradle of Liberty
The Sword and Shield

Local Radio Shows

WMBR 88.1 FM
What's Left
WEDS at 8:00 pm
Local Edition
FRI (alt) at 5:30 pm

WMFO 91.5 FM
Socialist Alternative
SUN 11:00 am

WZBC 90.3 FM
Sounds of Dissent
SAT at 11:00 am
Truth and Justice Radio
SUN at 6:00 am

Create account Log in
Comment on this article | View comments | Email this article | Printer-friendly version
Commentary :: Politics
STRIKE THE BLOW!!! - JOHN BROWN, REVOLUTIONARY FIGHTER
07 Feb 2006
Modified: 06:07:56 PM
FEBRUARY IS BLACK HISTORY MONTH SO IT IS APPROPRIATE TO HONOR THE MEMORY OF JOHN BROWN OF HARPER'S FERRY AND TRY TO LEARN THE LESSONS OF HIS FIGHT FOR OUR TIMES.
I would like to make a few comments on the role of Captain John Brown and his struggle at Harper’s Ferry in 1859 in the history of the black liberation struggle. This appropriate as I am writing this review during Black History Month of 2006. Unfortunately John Brown continues to remain one of the very few white heroes of the struggle for black liberation.

From fairly early in my youth I knew the name John Brown and was swept up by the romance surrounding his exploits at Harpers Ferry. For example, I knew that the great anthem of the Civil War -The Battle Hymn of the Republic had a prior existence as a tribute to John Brown. I, however, was then neither familiar with the import of his exploits for the black liberation struggle nor knew much about the specifics of the politics of the various tendencies in the struggle against slavery. I certainly knew nothing then of Brown’s (and his sons) prior military exploits in the Kansas wars against the expansion of slavery. If one understands the ongoing nature of his commitment to struggle one can only conclude that his was indeed a man on a mission. Those exploits also render absurd a very convenient myth about his ‘madness’. This is a political man and to these eyes a very worthy one. In the context of the turmoil of the times he was only the most courageous and audacious revolutionary in the struggle against the abolition of slavery in America.

Whether or not John Brown knew that his strategy would, in the short term, be defeated is a matter of dispute. Reams of paper have been spent proving the military foolhardiness of his scheme at Harper’s Ferry. This misses the essential political point that militant action not continuing parliamentary maneuvering advocated by other abolitionists had become necessary. What is not in dispute, however, is that Brown considered himself a true Calvinist avenging angel in the struggle against slavery and more importantly acted on that belief. In short, he was committed to bring justice to the black masses. This is why his exploits and memory stay alive after over 150 years.

Brown and his small integrated band of brothers fought bravely and coolly against great odds. Ten of Brown's men were killed including two of his sons. Five were captured, tried and executed, including Brown. These results are almost inevitable when one takes up a revolutionary struggle against the old order and one is not victorious. One need only think of, for example, the fate of the defenders of the Paris Commune in 1871. One can fault Brown on this or that tactical maneuver. Nevertheless he and the others bore themselves bravely in defeat. As we are all too painfully familiar there are defeats of the oppressed that lead nowhere. One thinks of the defeat of the Chinese Revolution in the 1920’s. There other defeats that galvanize others into action. This is how Brown’s actions should be measured by history.

Militarily defeated at Harpers Ferry, Brown's political mission to destroy slavery by force of arms nevertheless continued to galvanize important elements in the North at the expense of the pacifistic non-resistant Garrisonian political program for struggle against slavery. Many writers on Brown who reduce his actions to that of a ‘madman’ still cannot believe that his road proved more appropriate to end slavery than either non-resistance or gradualism. That alone makes short shrift of such theories. Historians and others have also misinterpreted later events such as the Bolshevik strategy which led to Russian Revolution in October 1917. More recently, we saw this same incomprehension concerning the victory of the Vietnamese against overwhelming military superior forces. Needless to say, all these events continue to be revised by some historians to take the sting out of there proper political implications.

From a modern prospective Brown’s strategy for black liberation, even if the abolitionist goal he aspired to was immediately successful reached the outer limits within the confines of capitalism. Brown’s actions were meant to make black people free. Beyond that goal he had no program. Unfortunately the subsequent Civil War did not provide fundamental economic and political freedom. That is still our fight. Moreover, the Civil War, the defeat of Radical Reconstruction, the reign of ‘Jim Crow’ and the subsequent waves of black migration to the cities changed the character of black oppression in the U.S. from Brown’s time. Black people are now a part of "free labor," and the key to their liberation is in the integrated fight of labor for the smashing of capitalism, its state and its institutions, and the establishing of a some form of workers government. Nevertheless, we can stand proudly in the revolutionary tradition of John Brown (and of his friend Frederick Douglass). We need to complete the unfinished democratic tasks of the Civil War, not by emulating Brown’s exemplary actions but to moving the multi-racial American working class to power. Finish the Civil War.

This work is in the public domain
Add a quick comment
Title
Your name Your email

Comment

Text Format
Anti-spam Enter the following number into the box:
To add more detailed comments, or to upload files, see the full comment form.

Comments

Re: STRIKE THE BLOW!!! - JOHN BROWN, REVOLUTIONARY FIGHTER
07 Feb 2006
You analysis of John Brown began with a great degree of historical accuracy. John Brown was indeed imbued with the Calvinist notion of pre-ordination and that his role in this pre-ordination was to set in motion the wheels of justice to free the enslaved negroes in the south. This is in part evident in what you so rightly point out as his militarily inept assault on the armory at Harper's Ferry. As far as brown was concerned he was merely an instrument in God's pre-ordained plan to liberate the slaves. Military strategy and or doctrine was not a consideration. Thus, he and his followers were soundly defeated with not much of a fight by United States Army Lieutenant Colonel Robert E. Lee. However, make no mistake that John Brown was not a socialist or anti-capitalist. John Brown was neither a capitalist nor socialist. His world view was that of pre-determination. To try to superimpose a late 19th or 20th century marxist or socialist philosophy on a man whose sole mission was freeing negroes from bondage is misguided.
Re: STRIKE THE BLOW!!! - JOHN BROWN, REVOLUTIONARY FIGHTER
08 Feb 2006
marx and engels wrote communist manifesto in 1847
adam smith wrote wealth of nations in 1776

john brown did identify with socialist ideas of small-scale farmers fighting large manufacturers, when he managed a wool-producers' cooperative and fought to gain better prices from the industry mafia. he went as far as to travel to europe to find higher-paying buyers but was frustrated to find the same capitalist conditions oppressing small producers, and had to revert to small-scale farming himself in order to feed his family in dire poverty.
John Brown's Sexy Body
08 Feb 2006
Why strike the blow when you can blow the strike?

Scabs of the World Unite!
Re: STRIKE THE BLOW!!! - JOHN BROWN, REVOLUTIONARY FIGHTER
08 Feb 2006
However, trying to assign late 1890s and early to late 1900s socialism to John Brown is absurd. Brown's singular purpose was the emancipation of negro slaves. Brown was also a supporter of sending freed negroes to Liberia.
Re: STRIKE THE BLOW!!! - JOHN BROWN, REVOLUTIONARY FIGHTER
09 Feb 2006
you don't seem to have dealt with the reality of his socialist life. what's your point again?