US Indymedia Global Indymedia Publish About us
Printed from Boston IMC :
IVAW Winter Soldier

Winter Soldier
Brad Presente

Other Local News

Spare Change News
Open Media Boston
Somerville Voices
Cradle of Liberty
The Sword and Shield

Local Radio Shows

WMBR 88.1 FM
What's Left
WEDS at 8:00 pm
Local Edition
FRI (alt) at 5:30 pm

WMFO 91.5 FM
Socialist Alternative
SUN 11:00 am

WZBC 90.3 FM
Sounds of Dissent
SAT at 11:00 am
Truth and Justice Radio
SUN at 6:00 am

Create account Log in
Comment on this article | View comments | Email this article | Printer-friendly version
News :: Human Rights
China rebuffs U.S. ‘human rights’ study
21 Mar 2006
....But Abu Ghraib prison, with many of its most horrifying photographs still under wraps; Guantanamo’s atrocities; “secret” renditions of U.S. prisoners to be tortured by client police states; the CIA’s boasts that the U.S. has developed “touchless torture”; which relies on sensory overload or deprivation to destroy a prisoner’s psyche; the death penalty, widely used by U.S. courts, and the fiasco of Katrina have exposed U.S. hypocrisy to all the world....
China rebuffs U.S. ‘human rights’ study

By G. Dunkel

U.S ruling circles use concern over human rights as a political and ideological weapon against anyone challenging them. The “human rights” gambit was honed during the Cold War and now is employed against a wide range of countries—from China and Russia to Belarus, Iran, Zimbabwe, Venezuela and Cuba—to serve the needs of U.S. foreign policy.

One of the highpoints of Washington’s use of this tactic is the annual State Department report on human rights, released this year with grand fanfare March 8.

The U.S. government tries to use alleged human rights violations to justify its interventions and threats to intervene. Afghanistan, Iraq and Haiti are three recent examples. This alleged concern for democracy and other high ideals lets Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice say with a straight face: “Our promotion of human rights and democracy is in keeping with America’s most cherished principles and it helps to lay the foundation for lasting peace in the world.”

But Abu Ghraib prison, with many of its most horrifying photographs still under wraps; Guantanamo’s atrocities; “secret” renditions of U.S. prisoners to be tortured by client police states; the CIA’s boasts that the U.S. has developed “touchless torture”; which relies on sensory overload or deprivation to destroy a prisoner’s psyche; the death penalty, widely used by U.S. courts, and the fiasco of Katrina have exposed U.S. hypocrisy to all the world.

Members of Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC), which is China’s top advisory body, held a panel on the U.S. report March 10, two days after it appeared, according to an English-language dispatch from the news agency Xinhua. For the past seven years, China has released a report on violations of human rights in the United States in response to the one the U.S. State Department releases.

“The United States, a self-proclaimed ‘human rights judge,’ has once again pointed its fingers at others while totally ignoring its own problems,” said Zhao Qizheng who formerly was minister in charge of the Information Office of the State Council, the Chinese cabinet.

According to Yang Zhengquan, another CPPCC member, the U.S. criticism on China has nothing to do with human rights but aims at “undermining China’s socialist system.”

“It’s nothing but dirty politics, which is totally ideology-oriented,” he said. “The United States is attempting to achieve its political goals under the pretext of human rights.”

Chinese reply strikes home

China’s report on U.S. violation of human rights is divided into seven parts: on life and security of person; on infringements upon human rights by law enforcement and judicial organs; on political rights and freedom; on economic, social and cultural rights; on racial discrimination; on rights of women and children; and on the United States’ violation of human rights in other countries.

The report summarizes these issues from a perspective of a different society and a different political system. For someone living in the United States, it is painful to recall all the depravities and inequities listed, including racism, homelessness, high homicide rates, violence against women and the ever-rising level of incarceration in prison:

“As the prisons in the U.S. were packed, the situation of prisoners worsened.

“During Hurricane Katrina, between Aug. 29 and Sept. 1, 2005, correctional officers from the New Orleans Sheriff’s Department abandoned 600 inmates in a prison, as many were immersed in chest- and neck-level water and left without food, water, electricity, fresh air, or functioning facilities for four days and nights.”

The report concludes, “The United States has always boasted it was the ‘model of democracy’ and hawked its mode of democracy to the rest of the world. In fact, American ‘democracy’ is always one for the wealthy and a ‘game for the rich’.”

The full Chinese report is available in English at

The U.S. media recently publicized the income disparity between rural and urban areas in China, which does exist but ignore that the gap between richest and poorest in the United States is far greater. The U.S. State Department’s report makes much of the “disturbances” in rural areas that “are suppressed.”

Chang Cheng, another member of the CPPCC, said that Washington has long ignored the constant progress of human rights in China.

This year the Chinese government announced several major preferential policies to promote rural development, which will bring about substantial benefits for the country’s 900 million farmers. “These policies will help better guarantee the farmers’ right to subsistence and development, which we believe is the primary right for every human being,” Chang said.

Perhaps the State Department didn’t mention China’s steps to achieve economic human rights for its citizens, because at the same time the Bush administration and a majority from both parties in Congress have enacted, along with sharp cuts in social services, tax cuts for the rich that will increase still further the disparity between rich and poor in the United States.

-- 30 --

Union labor donated
See also:

This work is in the public domain
Add a quick comment
Your name Your email


Text Format
Anti-spam Enter the following number into the box:
To add more detailed comments, or to upload files, see the full comment form.


Re: China rebuffs U.S. ‘human rights’ study
21 Mar 2006
People all over the world, and in China, debate whether China is socialist, or capitalist. The bulk of China's heavy industry is still state controlled and not owned by Capitalists. That is a threat to Capitalists everywhere. That's why the US and other Imperialists want to see a counter-revolution in China to bring back capitalism.

The Stalinist bureaucracy is incapable of a cold, gradual restoration of capitalism from above. A capitalist counterrevolution in China would be accompanied by the collapse of Stalinist bonapartism and the political fracturing of the ruling Communist Party.

What would emerge from the collapse of a Stalinist bonapartist regime, capitalist restoration or proletarian political revolution, would depend on the outcome of the struggle of counterposed forces.

The Stalinists/Maoists who misrule China would not know a Workers Democracy if they saw one. Communism is supposed to be workers control of society, not parasites who sit at the top and dictate.

China needs a real Communist party like the one Lenin and Trotsky led in Russia. The Stalinist/Maoist misrulers of China do not believe in workers revolution. Mao made deals with US Imperialism against Vietnam as communist soldiers defeated the US army on the ground. Stalinist/Maoists organize nothing but betrayals

What happens in China is not a foregone conclusion. It will be determined through social struggle.
BREAKING NEWS: Pot Calls Kettle "Black"
22 Mar 2006
Of course the Chinese refute U.S. condemnation of their abysmal human rights record. And of course they say those charges are politically motivated. Because they are.

Just like when the Chinese point to the Hurricane Katrina "response" and all the bad things happening in the U.S., odds are they aren't making it up. They are, however, playing politics, too. As a rule, it's much, much easier to condemn human rights abuses abroad, especially for governments pursuing their own arcane diplomatic agendas.

For those of us who don't want to go along with a party line of any kind, though, it's often difficult to sort human rights abuses on some sort of scale. I would recommend not taking the Chinese govt's rebuttal anymore to heart than you might take the U.S.'s report. And I certainly would not go thinking that China-- because, you know, it ain't run by Bush-- is somehow morally superior.
Both governments suck-- both are very repressive.