US Indymedia Global Indymedia Publish About us
Printed from Boston IMC :
IVAW Winter Soldier

Winter Soldier
Brad Presente

Other Local News

Spare Change News
Open Media Boston
Somerville Voices
Cradle of Liberty
The Sword and Shield

Local Radio Shows

WMBR 88.1 FM
What's Left
WEDS at 8:00 pm
Local Edition
FRI (alt) at 5:30 pm

WMFO 91.5 FM
Socialist Alternative
SUN 11:00 am

WZBC 90.3 FM
Sounds of Dissent
SAT at 11:00 am
Truth and Justice Radio
SUN at 6:00 am

Create account Log in
Comment on this article | View comments | Email this article | Printer-friendly version
Commentary :: Human Rights : Media : Organizing : Politics
RCP Cries "Wolf" over Fascism
06 Feb 2005
Modified: 05:00:46 PM
A comment on RCP's current
"Battle for the Future" campaign:
Hysteria about "fascism" serves to hide
the essential role of the Democratic Party in
the political and economic system of imperialism
A comment on RCP's current "Battle for the Future" campaign (part 1):

Crying "Wolf" over Fascism

The Revolutionary Communist Party (RCP,USA) has recently begun distribution of a leaflet titled The Battle for the Future Will Be Fought from Here Forward. I respect the hard work and dedication of the good comrades around the RCP -- but I believe that it is important for activists to understand that much of what this leaflet says is pure and simple crap.

The main content of the leaflet is hysteria-mongering over the supposedly impending fascist danger from Bush and company. The RCP's leaflet (which really needs to be read to be fully appreciated) says that it is an "open question" whether any democratic rights at all will remain by the end of Bush's term.

Of couse all serious activists are concerned about the steady and increasing erosion of our civil and democratic rights. And yes, if Bush and company had their way, most of us probably would be rounded up and sent to interrogation/torture camps like those in Guantanamo Bay. But so what? Bush cannot make any major changes in how this country is run without the support and backing of the ruling bourgeoisie (ie: the class of big-time capitalists who own or control the corporations, the politicians, the police, courts, schools and media personalities) as a whole. And the bourgeoisie in the US has no compelling material interest, under present circumstances, that would lead it to endorse such a reckless gamble as would be involved in attempting the wholesale elimination of democratic rights and plunging the US into fascism.

Such a desperate course of action by the bourgeoisie would:
(a) instantly politicize tens of millions of people,
(b) destablize the entire system of bourgeois rule and
(c) destroy illusions in the bourgeois political system that the bourgeoisie
has carefully crafted and painstakingly cultivated over many decades.

As a general rule, the bourgeoisie of any modern, economically developed nation has only resorted to fascist measures (ie: the forcible suppression of all opposition via arrest, torture, summary execution or death squads) within the home country in periods of extreme crisis -- when its class rule was threatened. These, for example, were the circumstances in which the German bourgeoisie made its infamous gamble on Hitler. But the bourgeoisie does not prefer fascism (which it considers as clumsy and ill-suited to the needs of capitalist development in a modern economy). Rather the bourgeoisie prefers ordinary bourgeois democracy in which its class rule is carefully hidden behind a screen of supposedly democratic institutions (ie: parliaments, the so-called "free press" and the various legal parties which serve to pacify the masses with sweet songs).

The RCP's leaflet does not mention any of the above factors which would restrain the bourgeoisie from endorsing such a desperate gamble as would be entailed by plunging the US into fascism.

Pandering to the naive

Rather, the RCP's leaflet panders to (ie: encourages and reinforces) the worst and most naive prejudices (which are, unfortunately, all-too-common amongst most new activists) that some kind of fundamental distinction exists between the twin ruling parties of US imperialism.

(Of course there are distinctions between these two parties -- but these distinctions are more in the way of a division of labor between committed partners in which (1) the Democratic Party makes concessions to the mass movements when the people are aroused and (2) the Republicans then take back the concessions once the Democratic Party has managed to suck the life out of the mass movements and lull the masses back to sleep.)

Historically, the struggle against fascism has been used as an excuse to unite progressive activists with bourgeois parties in such a way that the progressive activists surrendered their independent agenda and became subordinate to the bourgeois parties. This, for example, is how the CPUSA (ie: the original Communist Party in the US) betrayed the workers and became subordinate to the Democratic Party machine in the mid-to-late 1930's.

I suspect however, that the RCP's current campaign of hysteria over fascism may have less to do with justifying unprincipled alliances with liberal-bourgeois trends -- and more to do with simply recruiting activists who (unaware that the current climate of repression is not more severe than the Palmer Raids of 1918-21 or the McCarthyite witchhunts, jailings and blacklists during the Cold War 1950's) may be somewhat alarmed by the comparatively mild (ie: compared to open fascism) forms of repression which activists in the U.S. face today.

We are more powerful with open eyes

In any event, RCP's recent leaflet is profoundly mistaken and does a disservice to the movement. The struggle against increasing repression will be far more powerful and effective when based on a solid, class-based analysis of how the bourgeois political system really works than on the basis of hysteria over a supposedly impending fascist danger.

When activists understand how our society really works -- how all the institutions and levers of capitalist society are part of a single orchestra -- they often experience a transformation from feeling powerless and being powerless -- to feeling powerful and being powerful -- because they understand at last how the ruling class, in spite of its seemingly all-powerful appearance -- is actually only a tiny minority in society -- and that this minority cannot rule by force alone -- that this minority stands in opposition to the material interests of the overwhelming majority of society -- and can only continue to rule as long as it is able to maintain an increasingly vulnerable system of political deception.

And when we understand how our movement is being held back -- when we understand the true weaknesses of our enemy -- and the true strengths of our own forces -- we will be far better prepared for the day when talk of fascism may be more than crying wolf.

Struggle for revolutionary mass movement
requires public criticism today

Finally -- for those supporters of the RCP or RCYB who may believe that this article is somehow "anti-party" -- understand that sincere criticism is often the most powerful form of genuine support. The RCP, through its decades of hard work such as in writing articles in support of the struggles of our class brothers and sisters here in the US and around the world, has earned the respect of many activists. But this only makes it all the more important to criticise its errors.

The object of this article is not simply to defend our movement against wrong ideas or even to assist the RCP to overcome its errors. There is also a larger purpose. If activists today are to successfully confront the challenges of our times -- then we must make serious and systematic use of all of the possibilities of the unfolding revolution in digital communications -- for the purpose of helping all of us understand the strengths and weaknesses of all the trends on the left.

Only in this way will we be able to build a conscious revolutionary mass movement and assemble the talent and dedication needed for a genuinely revolutionary mass organization. Such an organization would not only be able to distribute millions of copies of a leaflet (as RCP aims to do with this one) but (equally important) would also have the ability to defend its views in forums (such as this Indymedia thread) in ways that are concise, informative and even entertaining.

Ben Seattle -- January 28, 2005
Ben's views may not represent the views of
other activists in the Media Weapon community.

Isolated from one another we are easily defeated.
Connected to one another no force on earth can stop us.

Join Ben and other activists in the Media Weapon community.

With an email list, wiki, competing projects and a community of
activists who engage one another with sincerity and respect.

Open to all activists who want to see the development of
a mass movement for the elimination of bourgeois rule.

Another article about the theoretical weaknesses of the RCP's current leaflet (ie: a failure to acknowledge the necessity of fundamental democratic rights in the period ahead after bourgeoisie rule is overthrown) can be found at:
See also:

This work is in the public domain
Add a quick comment
Your name Your email


Text Format
Anti-spam Enter the following number into the box:
To add more detailed comments, or to upload files, see the full comment form.


Re: RCP Cries "Wolf" over Fascism
06 Feb 2005
so what you're saying, uhm, is that we shouldn't be worried, everything is FINE, there's NOTHING in the WORLD to be WORRIED ABOUT right now! don't be hysterical, sedate yourself!
Ignore reality and use logic to, um, RATIONALIZE
07 Feb 2005
Ben's comments remind me of the thoughts of a crab, looking at the well fed seagulls on the beach, and deciding that there is no danger. "After all," Ben the crab thinks, "their bellies are full and no rational seagull would waste his energy snatching up another crab!" But, unfortunately for the bill the crab, by the time his thought is finished, a greedy an irrational seagull swoops down, snatches him in her beak, and carries him away for lunch.
Reply to Spectator and Jake
07 Feb 2005
Hi Spectator,

No, I am not saying that "we shouldn't be worried". I am saying that our struggle against growing repression is more powerful if we keep our eyes open and base our actions on an understanding of how the society that we live in actually works.

Hi Jake,

Thanks for your comments.

I am arguing that the bourgeoisie which rules this country, as a class, acts on the basis of its material interest. I gave three reasons, above, why imposing fascism and taking away all democratic rights would run counter to bourgeois material interests at this time:

Such a desperate course of action by the bourgeoisie would:
(a) instantly politicize tens of millions of people,
(b) destablize the entire system of bourgeois rule and
(c) destroy illusions in the bourgeois political system that the bourgeoisie
. has carefully crafted and painstakingly cultivated over many decades.

Analogies about crabs and seagulls are entertaining -- but the conclusion one might draw from your story is that in order to be safe we should all hide under a rock. But if we are serious about dealing with reality -- and building a powerful struggle -- then we must give some reply to the 3 arguments above -- because otherwise we would remain ignorant of how the bourgeois political system really works -- and we would remain vulnerable to deceptive arguments from "powerful allies" who supposedly will help us to fight the growing repression.

The Democratic Party and their reformist flunkies argue that Bush and company are irrational. They argue that we must struggle to "return to rationality" (ie: place our hopes in saviors from within the establishment who will "return" us to "sane" policies).

But the war in Iraq is completely rational from the point of view of US imperialism (this is why the Democratic Party gave Bush authorization and money for it). The war has never been about WMD or bringing "democracy" to the Iraqi people. It is about permanently planting military bases in the Middle East in order to control the oil-rich region. This is what the Democratic Party and their reformist flunkies do not want us to see.

On the other hand, once we understand how the bourgeois political system works -- then we will be better able to build a powerful and conscious mass movement which aims to overthrow it.

Ben Seattle