US Indymedia Global Indymedia Publish About us
Printed from Boston IMC :
IVAW Winter Soldier

Winter Soldier
Brad Presente

Other Local News

Spare Change News
Open Media Boston
Somerville Voices
Cradle of Liberty
The Sword and Shield

Local Radio Shows

WMBR 88.1 FM
What's Left
WEDS at 8:00 pm
Local Edition
FRI (alt) at 5:30 pm

WMFO 91.5 FM
Socialist Alternative
SUN 11:00 am

WZBC 90.3 FM
Sounds of Dissent
SAT at 11:00 am
Truth and Justice Radio
SUN at 6:00 am

Create account Log in
Comment on this article | View comments | Email this article | Printer-friendly version
Commentary :: Education : Labor
Idle black men, tragically, aren't just a stereotype
24 Apr 2006
The black men I know best are all hard-working, accomplished professionals. They include my brother, a physician, and my buddies — lawyers, college professors, political consultants, journalists.
The black men I know best are all hard-working, accomplished professionals. They include my brother, a physician, and my buddies — lawyers, college professors, political consultants, journalists. I live in an insular world of middle-class affluence, rarely stumbling into the troubled universe of marginalized underachievers.

Until recently. After a contractor walked off the job, I was assigned the task of helping my mother find laborers to help complete her new house in my hometown, Monroeville, Ala., a small place with a declining textiles industry. The assignment led me into an alternative universe of black men without jobs or prospects or enthusiasm for hard labor.

My younger sister, an architect, appointed her Mexican-born father-in-law, an experienced carpenter (and American citizen), the new general contractor. I was to find men willing to help him paint, lift, scrape, fill, dig. The pay was hardly exorbitant — $6 an hour. But it seemed reasonable for unskilled labor. So I looked among unemployed high school classmates, members of my mother's church and men standing on nearby street corners.

The experience brought me face to face with every unappealing behavior that I'd heard attributed to idle black men but dismissed as stereotype. One man worked a couple of days and never came back. One young man worked 30 minutes before he deserted. Others promised to come to work but never did.

This story is hardly an academic overview. The evidence is anecdotal. But it jibes with the treatises I've read that portray a permanent underclass of black men with criminal records and low educational attainment, with multiple children and little cash.

These are men who can no longer count the military as an option because it doesn't want them. The armed forces seek high school graduates with decent reading and math skills to operate high-tech gizmos. By some estimates, the unemployment rate among black male high school dropouts in their 20s is 72 percent, while the comparable rate among young, uneducated white men is 34 percent, and among Latinos, 19 percent.

How did this happen? I cannot remember seeing such large numbers of idle black men when I was growing up. (Indeed, the unemployment rate in my hometown is higher than it used to be.) Is this the consequence of a dying manufacturing base that has stranded men who otherwise would have had jobs with decent wages and good benefits? And does the wave of illegal immigrants further marginalize uneducated black men?

Go to any construction site and count the black men among the menial laborers. You won't see many. Dig a little deeper and you'll find a web of stereotypes knotted up with some thorny truths. Among other things, employers in the building trades frequently brush aside black men in favor of Latinos — believing that immigrant labor is more reliable and certainly more docile. And every time a black man fails a drug test or disappears after a few days of work, he reinforces the stereotype, making it less likely that the employer will hire other black men. They are not judged as individuals. (I've heard the "I prefer Mexicans" excuse from black contractors as well as white ones.)

Some economists say that native-born laborers — black, white and brown — are simply discouraged by the low wages that so many employers can get away with paying to illegal workers. George Borjas and Lawrence Katz of Harvard University estimate that U.S. high school dropouts would earn as much as 8 percent more if it weren't for Mexican immigration. Of course, 8 percent of not much is still not much.

What if my mother had been offering $20 an hour? Would she have found more willing workers? Probably. But globalization has taught us that the less complex the task, the lower the wage it will attract in a global marketplace. That's especially true if labor is willing to move around. Besides, in my mother's case, the work simply would not have been available. She wouldn't have paid $20 an hour; she couldn't afford it.

My mother's house is finally finished, and she's planning a house-warming party. My sister's father-in-law worked from dawn to dusk, and he found enough willing workers to get the job done. So that part of the tale has a happy ending.

But I'm stuck with a sense of deep unease and frustration over the prospects of so many young black men who are being pushed further and further out to the margins — so far from the mainstream that they no longer identify with the rest of us. That story simply cannot end well.

This work is in the public domain
Add a quick comment
Your name Your email


Text Format
Anti-spam Enter the following number into the box:
To add more detailed comments, or to upload files, see the full comment form.


Re: Idle black men, tragically, aren't just a stereotype
24 Apr 2006
wow, it's hard to take this 'article' seriously. first of all, the stereotype applies to black men in general, not just those who stand idle on street corners. so why is the author trying to promote the stereotype by not acknowledging that members of all ethnic groups do the same thing? has she never noticed idle whites or latinos standing on street corners? the goal here seems to be to prove that the old canard of the lazy black man is truer than the 'liberal media' or the 'elite universities' are willing to allow in this country. bull, in other words.
if the author is really a black woman, my question would be whether it's possible for black people to be be racist against other black people? whatever you call it. there is a growing number of middle-class and upper-class people of color who identify more with their economic position and the well-to-do whites around them than with their own roots and histories of oppression. prominent members of the bush administration aside, you have ward connerly and other academics, as well as prominent people of color at think tanks who go out of their way to be self-hating flunkies for the status quo, and refuse to acknowledge the role of historical traumas like slavery and jim crow in explaining the class/race divides we all see in america.
Let's see, you pay slave wages and you call Black men "idle" (read "lazy") for being smart enough to refuse your offer?
24 Apr 2006
Get real! I'm a white guy and I'd walk off your job (or refuse to take it) for $6.00 per hour. Do nothing is worth more than $6.00 per hour. Hell, people pay thousands of dollars for a week of doing nothing - it's called a vacation. That, in itself, proves that doing nothing at all is worth more than you pay.
Re: Idle black men, tragically, aren't just a stereotype
25 Apr 2006
The issue of unemployed black young men and jobs taken by illegals is a legitimate issue. It is false to claim as Bush does that there are jobs Americans won't do. Americans are not recruited for these jobs, and living wages aren't paid. Let's take care of our own people first.

I'm not saying deport someone. but if we have affirmative action, we need to hire the American black man first before the illegal immigrant. Some illegals will voluntarily leave. No force or compulsion is needed. Just fairness, redemption of promises made to our black population, and enforcement of our labor laws. Mexicao must provide jobs for its people. American workers cannot pay the price for the corrupt oligarchy that rules Mexico.